To start, an angler must first decide how to determine what constitutes
muddy to clear water. Our rule of thumb is to lower a white jig in the water. With the line as a measuring stick,
if we can see the jig at a depth of 6 feet or more, we consider the water to be clear. If the jig vanishes between 2
to 6 feet deep, the water is stained or colored. if the jig disappears at 2 feet or less, the water is muddy or dark.
When searching for clear water crappie, a careful, quiet approach is critical. Fishing in limited
light also helps. They rely heavily on sight and can see an offering and more readily to chase lures. Be on the
water in early morning and late afternoon-early evening when light penetration is minimal and the fish are in the shallows
to feed. Take advantage of cloudy days and night-fishing in the summer months.
Line considerations are also very
important, because crappie can look closely at the prey before attacking in crystal-clear environment. I use about
a 4-pound test because it is more difficult for crappie to detect. As for lure selections, live baits are always a good
choice because there is nothing phony for crappie to observe. When using jigs, I use jigs weighing 1/32 oz. or smaller.
Go to lighter, more natural, more translucent colors. A pearl with silver, or spotted minnow, and colors with sparkles
In muddy waters, crappie usually stay in the shallow water areas because there
are lower oxygen levels in deeper water. The peak feeding times are usually during the brightest hours, in fact, the
best fishing in muddy water will often be during midday hours under sunny days.
Because visibility is severely limited,
they are less spooky and tend to be object-oriented. They rarely move any distance and usually locate near some type
of woody cover. Fishing close to brush, stumps, and other structures can be very productive.
An important thing
to remember, that muddy-water crappie rely more on sound, vibrations and odor to find food. Thus, they usually respond
better to live baits, because they can home in on the scent. If jigs are used, use attractants such as Berkley Crappie
Nibbles or Kodiak paste.
As for colors, Dark colors such as: Black, Brown, dark Blue and dark Red are like
silhouettes in mud.
In stained or colored waters, crappie behavior falls somewhere between the
clear and muddy water extremes, and fish may display a characteristic of either condition, depending on degree of stain.
With water color closer to the muddy extreme, of course, lean towards muddy-water methods. When visibility is in the
4 to 6 foot range, stick more to clear-water techniques.
As water gets more stained, go to brighter colors, such as whites,
yellows and oranges. When you reach the point of 2 to 4 feet of visibility, try brighter fluorescents like hi-vis Blues,
Pinks, Chartruese or Lime Green. In water thats stained a dark green or brown, use multi-color combinations. Use
Black/Chartruese or Pink/Yellow. or use something with a little glitter when the water is real dark. Almost always, I hook
minnows or Grubco wax worms with the jigs.
Be ready to adjust and experiment to changing water clarities.
With a little extra work and know-how, crappie usually can be found.